Local Elections 2023: Labour Eyes Power After Crushing Tory Losses

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer says his party is on track to win the next general election after the Tories were hammered in local polls across England. The Tories have lost 48 councils and more than 1,000 councillors, exceeding their worst predictions. Many Conservatives were furious at the scale of the losses, with some blaming Prime Minister Rishi Sunak. Labour says it is now the largest party in local government, surpassing the Tories for the first time since 2002. “The British public has sent a clear rejection of a prime minister who never had the mandate to begin with,” a Labour spokesperson said.

The elections of 230 councils in England were the first big test of Mr Sunak’s electoral popularity since he won the Tory leadership contest and became prime minister last October. The Liberal Democrats had what their leader Sir Ed Davey said was their “best result in decades”, taking control of 12 councils, mostly in Tory heartlands. The Green Party gained 241 seats – their best-ever result in local elections – and gained its first majority on an English council, in Mid-Suffolk, although they were overtaken as the biggest party by Labour in Brighton and Hove.

Mr Sunak admitted the results were “disappointing”, but said he did not detect “a massive groundswell of movement towards the Labour Party”. Sir Keir claimed the “fantastic” results showed his party was well placed to oust the Tories from government in a general election, expected next year. “Make no mistake, we are on course for a Labour majority at the next general election,” he told cheering activists in Medway in Kent, one of the councils his party has wrested from the Tories.

Labour won control of councils in areas that will be crucial battlegrounds in the general election, including Medway, Swindon, Plymouth, Stoke-on-Trent, and East Staffordshire. The BBC’s projected national vote share put Labour on 35%, the Tories on 26% and the Lib Dems on 20%. Labour’s projected nine-point lead represents its largest over the Conservatives on this measure since the party lost power in 2010.

Sir John Curtice, the polling expert, said this year’s results were “only a little short of calamitous for the Conservatives”. But the BBC’s political editor, Chris Mason, said the results suggested it would be hard for either the Conservatives or Labour to be confident of winning a majority at the next general election. He said there appears to be no appetite to move against Mr Sunak, after the Tories forced two prime ministers – Boris Johnson then Liz Truss – out of office last year. Still, some Conservatives are reeling from the results, with ousted councillors and critics of Mr Sunak venting their anger at the prime minister.

As the big picture became clearer, there was disagreement among Tories over who was to blame for the loss of so many councillors. The elections came amid a dire economic backdrop in the UK, with high inflation contributing to the worst cost-of-living crisis in decades. A figure loyal to Mr Johnson and Ms Truss told the BBC that Mr Sunak had “no option but to own these results”. In a seething statement, the person said: “He has been chancellor or prime minister for virtually all of the last three years and it was he and his supporters who forced Boris and then Liz out of office in order to install him in Downing Street.

“The old saying goes that ‘it is the economy, stupid’ that defines the choice voters have at the ballot box.” In Swindon, where Labour took control of the borough council for the first time in 20 years, ousted Tory council leader David Renard blamed “the cost of living and the performance of the government in the last 12 months” for his party’s woes locally. Mr Renard said although the prime minister had “started to stabilise things”, for voters in Swindon, “what had gone on before that was something that they didn’t like”.

The Conservative mayor of the Tees Valley, Ben Houchen, said the poor Tory performance was a partly a result of “the turmoil and upheaval of the last 12 months”. He said Labour had been “successful in making this a referendum on the government”, adding “people don’t feel like they can vote for us”. Nigel Churchill, a former Tory councillor who lost his seat on Plymouth Council – another Labour target – said “I think we can safely say” the Conservatives will lose the next general election.

“The general public do not trust them at the moment,” he said. But Education Minister Robert Halfon said this year’s local elections were always “going to be difficult” for his party. He said internal party divisions “didn’t help”, but claimed the losses were down to external factors, such as the cost-of-living crisis and problems in the NHS. “Every government during the mid-term, especially a government that has been in power for 13 years, always suffers losses in local elections,” he said. Other Tory MPs told the BBC that apathy – Conservative voters staying at home – was also a big problem for the party.

The Conservatives attempted to manage expectations before Thursday’s elections, with party chairman Greg Hands suggesting they could lose 1,000 council seats. In contrast, Labour sought to downplay its chances of success, predicting gains of about 400 seats. Most of the seats were last up for election in 2019, at a time when the UK was gripped by political turmoil over Brexit.

The seats up for grabs were mostly on district councils, responsible for services including bin collections, parks, public housing and planning applications. The rest of the elections were for a mixture of metropolitan and unitary councils – single local authorities that deal with all local services – and for four mayors. The elections were the first in England to see voter ID checks at polling stations. Some voters told the BBC they were turned away from polling stations, prompting critics to call for the ID rules to be dropped.